The potential of top prospects adds an exciting layer to fantasy baseball drafts and waiver wire activity. Identifying players with the talent and proximity to the big leagues who can make an immediate impact is key to gaining a competitive edge.
This list focuses exclusively on players who still hold MLB Rookie of the Year eligibility and are realistically positioned to contribute to fantasy rosters during the current 2025 season. Get ready to see some new faces!
Here are some of the top prospects generating buzz and poised to help your fantasy team right now:
Immediate Impact Prospects
These prospects are either already getting the call or are on the doorstep, flashing the skills needed to contribute in fantasy leagues immediately.
Chase Burns, RHP, Cincinnati Reds
Chase Burns is arguably the top prospect for fantasy impact right now. After dominating across multiple levels in the minors, reports indicate the Reds are calling him up for his MLB debut. While his first test against a formidable Yankees lineup in the hitter-friendly confines of Great American Ball Park presents a challenge, Burns possesses elite talent.
Current 2025 Minor League Stats: 12 G, 59 IP, 1.83 ERA, .170 BAA, 13 BB, 82 SO (High-A, Double-A, Triple-A)
With multiple bat-missing pitches and command that has been described as exceptional, Burns has the potential for immediate success. His long-term ceiling is that of an ace, and even if he doesn’t reach that peak instantly, his talent level makes him a must-add for fantasy managers looking for pitching help.
Jordan Lawlar, SS, Arizona Diamondbacks
Despite a brief and disappointing earlier stint in Arizona, Jordan Lawlar has bounced back with strong performance since returning to Triple-A Reno. While his batting average has seen a slight dip recently, his slugging percentage remains robust, and he’s continued to showcase his power and speed combination with more homers and stolen bases.
Current 2025 Minor League Stats: 52 G, .321/.411/.586, 10 HR, 18 SB, 30 BB, 60 SO (Triple-A Reno); 8 G, .000/.175/.000, 0 SB, 3 BB, 9 SO (Arizona)
Lawlar is demonstrating improved plate discipline, drawing walks as minor league pitchers appear hesitant to challenge the former first-round pick. He’s recognized as a true five-tool player with potentially elite upside among prospects at the higher minor league levels. When the Diamondbacks inevitably give him another shot this summer, fantasy managers should be ready to make the move.
Samuel Basallo, C/1B, Baltimore Orioles
Samuel Basallo continues his impressive run at Triple-A Norfolk, showcasing significant offensive firepower. He’s been particularly scorching hot in June, posting a remarkable .352/.435/.722 slash line with six home runs over a two-week stretch.
Current 2025 Minor League Stats: 43 G, .264/.371/.588, 15 HR, 0 SB, 28 BB, 46 SO (Triple-A Norfolk)
Beyond his hitting, Basallo has been seeing increased action at first base in addition to catcher, indicating the Orioles view him as a versatile asset for both the near and long term. While a summer promotion isn’t guaranteed, his performance makes it highly likely. Basallo’s offensive upside rivals that of any remaining prospect in the minors.
Harry Ford, C, Seattle Mariners
Yes, another catcher, even in an organization already boasting one of the best in baseball (Cal Raleigh). However, Harry Ford’s performance warrants attention. He has been one of the top hitters in Triple-A Tacoma over the past month-plus.
Current 2025 Minor League Stats: 56 G, .306/.422/.468, 8 HR, 3 SB, 41 BB, 47 SO (Triple-A Tacoma)
Ford offers more than just hitting; his athleticism allows him to play in the outfield and first base, providing Seattle with flexibility. Given the current situation on the big league roster, there are potential avenues for Ford to see significant at-bats if promoted. His tools suggest he can become a fantasy-relevant player once he gets the opportunity.
Andrew Painter, RHP, Philadelphia Phillies
Welcome Andrew Painter to the list. On paper, his 2025 numbers might not jump out, but they’ve been trending upward recently. More importantly, the raw stuff is undeniable.
Current 2025 Minor League Stats: 12 G, 47.1 IP, 4.18 ERA, .243 BAA, 18 BB, 58 SO (Low-A, Triple-A)
Standing 6-foot-7, Painter boasts three swing-and-miss pitches. While he’s battled some command inconsistencies this year, there’s little long-term concern about his ability to throw strikes at a level sufficient for a big league starter. The Phillies are likely to be cautious with Painter after he missed the previous two seasons, but he possesses the talent to be an immediate roster addition for fantasy managers as soon as the call-up happens.
Heating Up & On The Horizon
These prospects may not be quite as imminent as the names above, but their recent performance has significantly boosted their fantasy stock for late-season call-ups or keeper leagues.
Colt Emerson, SS, Seattle Mariners
Colt Emerson ranks as the top prospect in a deep Mariners system, and his recent play has only solidified that status. He’s been exceptionally hot at the plate lately.
Recent Stretch (Last 10 Games): .438/.550/.781 with 2 HR and 2 SB
A first-round pick in 2023, Emerson is praised for having one of the best pure hitting tools in the minors, regardless of level. He’s also starting to tap into more power, complementing his ability to stick at shortstop. Emerson’s bat projects well wherever he plays, and while he might be more of a 2026 everyday option, his current tear makes him someone to monitor closely.
Alex Freeland, SS/3B, Los Angeles Dodgers
Alex Freeland is making a strong case for attention, posting a solid .857 OPS in 2025 and elevating his game even further recently.
Recent Stretch (Last Month/10 Games): 7 HR over the last month, .703 SLG over the last 10 games.
Freeland grades out with above-average hit and power tools (55-grade) and provides solid defense at shortstop and third base. While a clear path to the Dodgers’ big league roster might require an injury given the current lineup, especially with Max Muncy’s struggles, Freeland appears to be the long-term future at the position. He’s a prime target for fantasy managers in keeper formats.
Henry Baez, RHP, San Diego Padres
Looking for a promising young pitcher who isn’t getting widespread national hype? Henry Baez fits the bill. He’s been outstanding at Double-A San Antonio this season.
Current 2025 Minor League Stats: 14 GS, 70 IP, 2.06 ERA, 69 SO, 22 BB, 1.04 WHIP (Double-A)
Baez might not possess a triple-digit fastball, but his entire arsenal has the potential to play as above-average. His command is strong enough to allow his pitches to be effective in a starting role, with potential for his stuff to play up even more in relief. A promotion to Triple-A seems imminent, and if he handles that challenge well, a big league debut for San Diego by year’s end isn’t out of the question, though 2026 is a more likely target. He’s another intriguing arm for those focusing on keeper leagues.
Keep a close eye on these names. Prospect developments happen quickly, and adding one of these rising stars to your roster at the right time could provide a significant boost for your fantasy baseball championship run.
