A new era for the DC Universe takes flight with the release of James Gunn’s highly anticipated superman film. The first wave of critical reactions has landed, painting a vivid picture of what viewers can expect. Starring David Corenswet as the iconic hero and Rachel Brosnahan as the dynamic Lois Lane, this movie is being widely hailed. critics praise its vibrant, classic comic book feel and see it as a fun, hopeful kickoff for the relaunched DCU. This film was notably ranked the most anticipated movie of July 2025 by Rotten Tomatoes readers, signaling significant fan excitement before reviews even arrived.
Many reviewers agree that this Superman film delivers a refreshing experience. It captures an “old-school charm” that feels nostalgic and welcome. Some critics call it potentially the “best Superman movie” of their lifetime. Others rank it as “next-level good,” placing it alongside successful superhero entries like Iron Man or Batman Begins. While it might not reach the absolute pinnacle of the genre for every reviewer, it generally represents superhero cinema well.
Returning to Heroic Ideals
A key strength highlighted in reviews is the film’s embrace of Superman’s inherent idealism. In a cinematic landscape often dominated by dark anti-heroes, this optimistic approach feels “refreshingly idealistic.” Some find this positive portrayal even “rebellious” or “radical.” Critics note that the film aligns more closely with the character’s on-page adventures than many past cinematic versions. This grounding in the source material resonates strongly with audiences and critics alike.
The film successfully embodies a sense of “child-like wonder” and escapism. It largely avoids the “revisionist murk” seen in superhero movies over the past two decades. This makes it feel like a genuine “breath of fresh air” for the genre. James Gunn appears intent on resetting expectations for comic-book films, prioritizing fun and vibrancy. The deliberate use of bright colors serves as a “visual promise” of enjoyment.
Casting Takes Flight: Corenswet and Brosnahan Shine
David Corenswet steps into the massive shoes of Clark Kent/Superman with notable success. Reviewers describe his performance as “outstanding” and an “inspired choice” to anchor the new DCU. His portrayal is noted for its warmth, “self-irony,” charm, and “poignant vulnerability.” Corenswet evokes Christopher Reeve without simply mimicking the legendary actor. His performance is seen as nuanced, “extremely physical and emotive.” This earnest transparency in his acting “will win the hearts of fans.” One critic felt they weren’t just watching someone play Superman, but “simply watching Superman.”
Rachel Brosnahan earns equally strong praise as Lois Lane. Many reviewers call her “an absolute force” in the role. Her portrayal reclaims the essence of Lois as sharp, confident, and unrelenting. She’s a character capable of challenging powerful figures while still breaking the biggest stories. Brosnahan injects her performance with a “propensity for wisecracking.” Some reviews declare her the “best onscreen Lois we’ve ever had.” She is seen as possibly the sharpest interpretation since Margot Kidder’s iconic take. Brosnahan brings a self-possessiveness to the role that critics found essential.
Electric Chemistry and Memorable Supporting Cast
The chemistry between Corenswet and Brosnahan is consistently cited as a major highlight. It’s described as “electricity” that “blasts off” when they share a scene. Their “sparkling” banter and genuine emotional connection are crucial to the film’s success. Reviewers found their rapport “funny,” “scrappy,” and utterly delightful. The dynamic between the “goofy but swoony Corenswet” and the “all-American but sexy Brosnahan” leaves audiences wanting more. Their chemistry is noted as both romantic and built on mutual respect.
The supporting cast also features standout performances. Nicholas Hoult is frequently mentioned for his take on Lex Luthor. Some critics state he “absolutely owns” the film. He is seen as potentially the “most fascinating interpretation since Gene Hackman.” Hoult is praised for “chewing every piece of scenery” while blending menace with self-absorption. His performance draws comparisons to various past Lex Luthor portrayals, including those by Hackman, Michael Rosenbaum, and Jesse Eisenberg.
Beyond the main villain, other characters stole scenes. Krypto the Superdog is described as “absurd, adorable, and very on-brand” for James Gunn’s style. Edi Gathegi earns praise as Mister Terrific. His “hilariously deadpan” portrayal is called the “standout human performance.” Many felt Gathegi was born to play the part. Skyler Gisondo also impresses as Jimmy Olsen, stealing the show whenever he appears. These varied supporting characters contribute significantly to the movie’s energy and charm.
James Gunn’s Vision: Comic Book Come to Life
James Gunn’s direction receives considerable attention in the reviews. He is praised for creating a film that genuinely feels like a “comic book come to life.” Gunn is unafraid to embrace core comic book elements and the fantastical nature of the source material. Some critics describe his approach as delivering the most “Silver Age comic book saga ever put to screen.” The film replicates the colorful visuals, humor, “clever quips,” and lightheartedness of vintage comics. One reviewer felt it strongly resembled Superman: The Animated Series.
Gunn skillfully draws from a vast array of Superman lore. He takes elements from comics, TV shows like Smallville, and the classic Donner films, treating them like a “grab bag.” The movie drops the audience straight into the action, assuming a certain familiarity with the characters and world. This approach reveals an obvious love for Richard Donner’s 1978 film and its 1981 sequel, Superman II. It pays homage without becoming overly reverential or self-serious. Corenswet and Brosnahan’s final scene together is specifically noted for capturing the magic of the 1978 film’s romance.
While generally praised for his comfort with the material, some reviews note moments where the tone feels uneven. One critic described the shifts as “jarring,” moving from familiar superhero beats to “out-there eccentrics.” However, others argue that Gunn’s ability to juggle a large cast and multiple plot threads is a testament to his skill. When Gunn leans into earnestness and challenges himself, the film is at its strongest. When he reverts to more familiar, comfort-zone elements (like a specific subplot mentioned), the film can falter slightly.
Action, Themes, and Potential Pitfalls
The action sequences are described as “larger than life” and “dazzlingly superhuman.” Gunn proves skilled at balancing big action with quieter character moments that strengthen relationships. A memorable set piece involves a one-man fight against Luthor’s army. This sequence is praised for being seamlessly shot in a continuous long take from a unique perspective. The introduction of Superman’s rival vigilante team, the Justice Gang, also adds thrilling dynamics to the action.
The script is seen as layered with relevant political subtext. Themes of immigration, power, and media misinformation are present but handled without feeling preachy. Despite this thematic depth, one review felt the screenplay sometimes lacked emotional depth and storytelling clarity. While the film has a warm human heart and a deeply emotional core, Gunn’s sincerity can occasionally feel overt, like dialogue describing kindness as “punk rock.”
One recurring criticism is the potential for the movie to feel “overcrowded.” With a packed narrative and multiple subplots establishing the new DCU, some feel “too many things are going on at once.” The inclusion of numerous super-powered supporting characters leads some to argue that Superman’s own ethical challenges are resolved too easily. While some reviews acknowledge the busyness, they argue it never feels overwhelming. They note that Superman remains central to every plot line. However, other critics felt the busy pace meant the film rarely slowed down for characters to process events. Despite these concerns, the introduction of several intriguing new DC heroes left many eager to see them again.
A Bright Future for the New DCU?
The overwhelming sentiment among critics is that Superman serves as a “thrilling and emotionally rich new beginning” for the DC Universe. Many feel the franchise is “in great hands” if this film represents the starting point. The movie successfully introduces a variety of characters intended for future projects without feeling like forced exposition or fan service. It lays groundwork for the DCU not through needless cliffhangers but by enriching its own story with engaging supporting players.
Instead of just setting up a universe, Gunn reportedly prioritized making a movie people would simply enjoy watching. This approach seems to have paid off. The film functions well both as a standalone story and as a foundation for others. It introduces characters like Mister Terrific and the Justice Gang naturally within the narrative. Reviewers are left wanting to explore these characters further in future installments. The film feels like the “best possible way to relaunch a franchise.”
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the general critic reaction to James Gunn’s new Superman movie?
Critical reception for James Gunn’s Superman is largely positive. Reviewers praise the film for its fun, classic comic book tone, vibrant visuals, and hopeful idealism, which feels refreshing. Many see it as a strong return to form for the character and a promising start to the new DC Universe. While some mention it might feel slightly overcrowded with characters or subplots, the overall consensus is that it’s an engaging and enjoyable superhero film.
How did critics review David Corenswet and Rachel Brosnahan’s performances in Superman?
David Corenswet as Superman/Clark Kent and Rachel Brosnahan as Lois Lane received widespread acclaim. Critics called Corenswet an “outstanding” and inspired choice, highlighting his warmth, vulnerability, and ability to evoke Christopher Reeve without mimicry. Brosnahan was praised as an “absolute force,” reclaiming Lois’s sharp, confident essence. The chemistry between Corenswet and Brosnahan is consistently noted as a major strength, described as electric and crucial to the movie’s success.
Does the Superman movie successfully launch the new DC Universe according to reviews?
Based on early reviews, the Superman movie is seen as a successful launch for the new DC Universe. Critics believe it lays a solid foundation by introducing several interesting supporting characters naturally within the story, making audiences eager to see them again. The film prioritizes being a good movie on its own terms rather than just forced setup, which reviewers found effective. The general sentiment is that the DCU is off to a promising start with this film.
Conclusion
The first wave of Superman movie reviews paints an overwhelmingly positive picture. Critics celebrate James Gunn’s vision for bringing a bright, idealistic, and classic comic book feel back to the character. The performances of David Corenswet and Rachel Brosnahan, especially their chemistry, are highlighted as core strengths. While some minor criticisms point to a potentially overstuffed narrative, the film is widely seen as a fun and effective launchpad for the ambitious new DC Universe. It seems the Man of Steel has successfully flown into a promising future.
